Why do so many students decide to seek Ph.D.’s, even knowing what they know about the academic labor system?
No one asks a corporate lawyer whether he protects the interests of his clients for “love.”
by William Pannapacker, PhD • Hope College
Graduate school is often described as a labor of love. But “love” is a troublesome word. It often is applied to undercompensated work done mostly by women.
It’s also typically applied to “soft” academic fields that are “feminized” (i.e., institutionally disempowered), such as the humanities, but not to male-dominated “hard” fields, such as physics or engineering.
No one asks a corporate lawyer whether he protects the interests of his clients for “love.”
The word hovers in the background of salary negotiations in academe:
“Since you are doing this for ‘love,’ we don’t need to pay you more than we currently do. Maybe we don’t need to pay you at all. You should do this work for its own sake. Maybe you should pay us?”